Fischer's semicompatibilism and its consequences

Published date
2018
Resource type
Publisher
Assumption University Press
ISBN
ISSN
1513-6442
DOI
Call no.
Other identifier(s)
Edition
Copyrighted date
Language
eng
File type
application/pdf
Extent
18 pages
Other title(s)
Advisor
Other Contributor(s)
Citation
Prajna Vihara: The Journal of Philosophy and Religion 19, 1 (January-June 2018), 69-86
Degree name
Degree level
Degree discipline
Degree department
Degree grantor
Abstract
In this paper I argue that the symmetric approach to moral responsibility, proposed by John Martin Fischer, should be focused merely on the consequence-particular. Fischer employs the symmetric approach with the intention to solve the asymmetric problems on moral responsibility. The problem arises from Frankfurt’s case, which rejects the principle of alternate possibilities (PAP), and relies on the action, rather than omission resulting in asymmetric problems. Fischer solves the problem by using his guidance control and returns the symmetry the idea of moral responsibility. I am convinced by his idea of guidance control that moral responsibility for an omission is the same as moral responsibility for an action. Notwithstanding, I found that Fischer appears to broaden his conclusion from the consequence-particular to the consequence-universal. This issue becomes more explicit when he argues against the case of “direct argument”. But I contend that this argument is unnecessary. The attempt to stretch out responsibility to the consequence-universal is only designed to address a certain kind of problem in his moral responsibility’s theory. This can also be seen when Fischer tries to solve other problem by using his overdetermination example. I believe that his theory of moral responsibility and guidance control should limit itself merely to the consequenceparticular.
Table of contents
Description
punsarn.dc.description.sponsorship
Spatial Coverage
Keyword(s)
Rights
This work is protected by copyright. Reproduction or distribution of the work in any format is prohibited without written permission of the copyright owner.
Access rights
Rights holder(s)
Location
View External Resources